"Images of a Shrinking and Damaged Planet" and High Commodity Prices
Robert Shiller says when it comes to commodity prices, images that portray the earth as small and vulnerable matter:
Seeing is believing, by Robert Shiller, Project Syndicate: Could the television image we’ve all seen of the Greenland ice cap crumbling into the ocean because of global warming somehow - indirectly and psychologically — be partly responsible for high oil and other commodity prices? The usual explanation ... focuses on explosive growth in emerging countries, China and India in particular... But psychology also matters in speculative markets, and perhaps that image of the Greenland ice disappearing makes it seem all too plausible that everything else- land, water, even fresh air - is running out too.
Let’s take a case study, the last generalised boom-bust cycle in commodity prices, which caused these prices generally to rise (more or less) from some time in the 1960’s until the 1980’s, and then generally to fall until the mid-1990’s. ...
The conventional “fundamental” explanation for that cycle relates it to ...[t]he 1973-1974 oil crisis... [and the] 1979-1981 oil crisis... The drop in oil prices after the mid-1980’s is said to be due to the collapse of the OPEC oil cartel. But ... these events don’t really explain why prices of other commodities followed that of oil.
Maybe more important than those wars in the 1970’s was that people throughout the world got worried about running out of things. This was the time of the “great population scare,” which transformed thinking worldwide, no doubt contributing to higher commodity prices while the fear lasted.
There seemed to be some basis for this scare. The rate of increase in the world’s population rose from 1.8 per cent in 1951 to 2.1 per cent in 1971. But those were just dry statistics. Images likely mattered more. ...
The first photograph of the earth from space came as part of the Apollo project in November 1967. One of the Apollo astronauts, James B. Irwin ... said of his view of the earth, “It was so far away... a little ball in the blackness of space. That does something to your soul... We saw how fragile our planet is...”... That image of the earth from space had a profound psychological effect, and we all saw it. Maybe that image was at least part of the reason why people became so worried in the 1970’s about population running ahead of resources.
The Club of Rome’s monumental book The Limits to Growth came out in 1972, with a picture of the earth on its cover. The book, written by a team of scientists, predicted disastrous shortages and mass starvation due to population pressure. Despite scientific critics of the Club of Rome’s methods, the public was ready to believe the dire forecast.
The great population scare led to various birth-control efforts around the world, notably to the “one-child policy” instituted in China in 1979. Partly due to such efforts, as well as to a change in family values, the rate of growth of the world’s population, began a long decline, to 1.1 per cent in 2005. That gradual decline led to gradual loss of concern about limits to growth. Commodity prices fell, too.
Today, we remain mostly unconcerned about global population growth. But, in the last ten years or so, we have become concerned about something else: rapid world economic growth. While it may seem that no image in the last decade was so dramatic as the first photo of the earth from space, think again.
Try searching YouTube, for example, on Greenland ice. More generally... The ability to communicate via email to everyone in the world creates a sense of the world’s smallness relative to the abundance of people in it.
We have seen photographs of hurricane and typhoon activity due to global warming, affecting people in Louisiana or Myanmar. We have seen devastation from the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, interpreted as a sign of crowding at the coasts.
The North Pole turned into a lake for the first time in 2000. We see aerial photos of the Aral Sea drying up. We practically can’t buy caviar from the Caspian Sea any more. The European Space Agency announced in September 2007 that satellite photos showed that the Northwest Passage appeared clear of ice for shipping for the first time ever, and that the Northeast Passage is almost clear.
With so many vivid images of a shrinking and damaged planet, is it really any wonder that human psychology is ripe for high commodity prices?
If this is the reason for high commodity prices, wouldn't we see evidence of hoarding? When there are appears to be more people at the party than there is food, how do people respond when they realize there won't be enough to go around? You can eat as early as possible so as to be sure to get your share, and that would increase the demand for food early in the party as everyone pursues the same strategy (driving up price if it is a market). And, if it is storable, you can stuff food in your pockets (or hide it somewhere else) so you'll be sure to have some later if you want it then. This also increases demand early in the party. It's the latter effect - storage for later - that seems to be missing from data on inventories.
Update: See Free Exchange for more.
Get Seeking Alpha Free Stock Alerts by Email!
Get Free Stock Alerts by Email!
ETFs In Focus
-
Editor's Picks
-
Most Popular
- Reading the S&P 500's Crashing Waves
- On a Return to Normalcy: Dow 8,500
- Looking Back at Lehman: Lying, Scapegoating and a General Lack of Accountability
- iShares ETF Tracking Error: Risks and Explanations
- U.S. vs. the World: Sectors Matter
- Global Stock Markets: The Crash of 2008?
- Full list of Editor's Picks »
- Nation's Debt: It's Not Being Rescued, It's Being Moved Around »
- Crazy P/E Ratios »
- Clueless - Cramer's Mad Money (10/8/08) »
- Wall Street Breakfast: Must-Know News »
- Cramer: Dow Could Drop Another 14%, Oil's Going to $50 »
- Roger Wiegand: 'Severe Bull Market' Ahead for Gold »
- Awaiting Apple Earnings and Guidance »
- Four Ways to Protect Money During the Fallout »
- Ford, GM on the Chopping Block? »
- Earnings Preview: General Electric »
- Cramer Should Be Suspended »
-
Long Ideas
-
Short Ideas
-
Cramer's Picks
- 'When There's Blood in the Streets', Buy Biotech Stocks
- Midstream MLPs Crashing, Present Opportunity
- A Fresh Look at Shipping Company Stocks
- Panic Selling in InterOil: What Now?
- Potash Corp.: No Liquidity Problems Here
- The Year of the Bear
- Cobalt: More Than Just Blue
- Investors Can Find Comfort in Big Blue
- Hershey: The Perfect Recession Investment?
- Applied Materials Leads by Example
- Full list of Long Ideas »
- The Short Case for General Electric
- Too Late to Short SPY? An Historical Perspective
- Henderson Group: Profit Warning Surprises Short Investors
- Decreasing Chipotle Traffic Could Spell Trouble
- Why I Sold Lowe's Short
- Accor, Host and Marriott: Short Interest Heats Up
- Global Financial Crisis Makes Oil a Great Hedge
- Michael Page International: Stock Down on Market Weakness
- Gaming Stocks Still a Poor Bet - Barron's
- After Coming Rate Cuts, Some Appealing Short ETFs
- Full list of Short Ideas »
- Clueless - Cramer's Mad Money (10/8/08)
- Torpedo Dry Ships - Cramer's Lightning Round (10/8/08)
- Chocolate Lover - Cramer's Mad Money (10/7/08)
- Yield is King - Cramer's Lightning Round (10/7/08)
- Goldman Disses Solar - Cramer's Stop Trading ! (10/7/08)
- Time to Hoard Cash - Cramer's Mad Money (10/6/08)
- Buyers On Strike - Cramer's Stop Trading! (10/6/08)
- Still Bullish on RIMM - Cramer's Lightning Round (10/6/08)
- The Cramer Crash?
- Cramer: Dow Could Drop Another 14%, Oil's Going to $50
- Full list of Cramers Picks »
Trading Center
Hedge Fund Jobs
Job Seekers: Search jobs by category, get job alerts by email or live feed, apply online See full list of jobs »
Employers: See all recruitment options, get applications online or by email Post a job »



This article has 2 comments:
Tiedeman