Prieur du Plessis

About this author: By this author:
Become a Contributor Submit an Article
  • Font Size:
  • Print

The gyrations of financial markets ahead of the Labor Day weekend tested the patience of bulls and bears alike. As big swings took place in thinly-traded markets, I was reminded of Albert Schweitzer’s words:

As we acquire more knowledge, things do not become more comprehensible but more mysterious.

None the wiser, I also did not succeed in capturing a leprechaun and finding the gold during my visit last week to the Emerald Isle. However, the beautiful Irish scenery, hospitality and “open for business” attitude resulted in a very successful trip and will keep me going back in search of the “buried treasure”.

Nervousness about the financial system was still paramount as investors realized that none of the problems were likely to be fixed anytime soon. The upshot of the week’s trading was a further weakening in credit markets, judging by the elevated credit spreads. Global stock and bond markets ended another volatile week on a mixed note, whereas crude prices gained surprisingly little on the impending arrival of Hurricane Gustav and a festering geopolitical situation with Russia.

Next, a tag cloud of the text of all the articles I have read during the past week. This is a way of visualizing word frequencies at a glance. As expected, words such as “banks”, “prices”, “credit” and “financial” featured prominently in my reading matter.

31-aug-v2.jpg

I do believe we are still in a primary bear market where at best, stock markets are faced with a prolonged convalescence period characterized by sub-optimal returns. Whether significant further declines will take place from these levels and valuations overshoot to bargain levels is anyone’s guess.

However, in the short term I give the nascent stock market rallies the benefit of the doubt provided the mid-July lows could be sustained. For any rally to become more enduring it will require further base building and an eventual shift in central bank policy to targeting GDP growth rather than inflation.

The rally’s lack of breadth, however, is worrying, causing Richard Russell (Dow Theory Letters) to warn:

If July 15 was a true bottom, the market should be roaring up today, and that’s not what’s been happening. Caution is warranted!

However, we should also take note of the fact that 64% of stocks in the S&P 500 are currently trading above their 50-day moving averages, as pointed out by Bespoke:

As shown in the chart below, the reading has been creeping higher and higher since mid-July, and looks to be on its way to the 80% to 85% levels seen twice over the last year. Readings above 50% are signs of a healthy market, and it hasn’t been above 50% for much of 2008.


 

Seasonality indicates that “September has firmly secured the rank as the worst month of the year” (Stock Trader’s Almanac), but that a year-end rally typically starts in late September / early October.

Before highlighting some thought-provoking news items and quotes from market commentators, let’s briefly review the financial markets’ movements based on economic statistics and a performance round up.

Economy
According to the Survey of Business Confidence of the World conducted by Moody’s Economy.com,

Global business sentiment remains weak and fragile and consistent with recession in the U.S., Europe and Japan.

The survey results suggest that the Asian economy (ex Japan) continues to post growth that is near its potential.

Across the globe, sentiment is consistent with an economy that is near recession. Pricing pressures remain very elevated, but fell notably last week.

The minutes from the FOMC meeting of August 5, released on Tuesday, indicate that committee members were concerned about the near-term risks to growth. Most participants expected inflation to fall, although they remained wary about upside risks to inflation. Given the problems in financial markets, members did not view current monetary policy as overly stimulative.

Other economic reports released in the U.S. during the past week included the following:

  • The GDP growth rate in the second quarter was revised upward to 3.3% from 1.9%, exceeding expectations. In the first quarter, real GDP increased by 0.9%. The better-than-expected outcome did not change most economists’ view that the economy was weakening, with the beneficial effects of rebate checks and foreign demand fading fast. Corporate profits edged down for the fourth straight quarter, falling twice as fast as in the first three months of the year.
  • New orders for durable goods rose by 1.3% in July, surpassing expectations for only a slight increase. Core capital goods orders also surprised on the upside, increasing by 2.6% over the month.
  • Existing home sales increased by 3.1% over the month in July, according to the National Association of Realtors. This increase put the annualized pace of sales up to five million units. However, substantial slack persisted, with inventories hitting a record high of 11.2 months. Furthermore, the median price of an existing house declined by 7.1% in year-ago terms, slightly worse than in June.
  • Personal income tumbled by 0.7% in July after rising by 0.1% in June. Excluding the tax rebate effect, disposable personal income rose by 0.5% in July, up from 0.3% in June. Spending growth slipped to 0.2% from 0.6% the previous month. Real spending fell by 0.4%, as price growth remained high. The core PCE deflator rose by 0.3%, matching the fastest rate since September, while the top-line deflator rose by 0.6%. The saving rate fell back to 1.2% from 2.5% in June but remained inflated by rebates.

 31-aug-v4.jpg

Source: Slate

Summarizing the U.S. economic situation, John Mauldin (Thoughts from the Frontline) said:

Even many mainstream economists are now suggesting we will be in a recession by the fourth quarter, if we are not in one now. The recovery, when it comes, will be tepid until credit spreads signal an end to the credit crisis. It is going to be Muddle Through for 2009. This is NOT going to be good for the stock market. When will it be safe to get back into the water? Pay attention to credit spreads.

Data releases from Europe and Japan underlined rapidly deteriorating economies flirting with recession. The Japanese government announced a $107 billion set of fiscal measures, including tax cuts and larger government-guaranteed loans, in response to the weakening economy.

Week’s economic reports

Date
Time (ET)
Statistic
For
Actual
Briefing Forecast
Market Expects
Prior
Aug 25
10:00 AM
Jul
5.00M
4.95M
4.90M
4.85M
Aug 26
10:00 AM
Aug
56.9
53.0
53.0
51.9
Aug 26
10:00 AM
Jul
515K
535K
525K
503K
Aug 26
2:00 PM
FOMC Minutes
Aug 5
-
-
-
-
Aug 27
8:30 AM
Jul
1.3%
0.2%
0.0%
1.3%
Aug 27
10:35 AM
Crude Inventories
08/23
-177K
NA
NA
9390K
Aug 28
8:30 AM
Chain Deflator-Prel.
Q2
1.2%
1.1%
1.1%
1.1%
Aug 28
8:30 AM
GDP-Prel.
Q2
3.3%
2.8%
2.7%
1.9%
Aug 28
8:30 AM
08/23
425K
425K
425K
435K
Aug 29
8:30 AM
Jul
-0.7%
-0.5%
-0.2%
0.1%
Aug 29
8:30 AM
Personal Spending
Jul
0.2%
0.3%
0.2%
0.6%
Aug 29
9:45 AM
Aug
57.9
50.5
50.0
50.8
Aug 29
10:00 AM
Mich Sentiment-Rev.
Aug
63.0
63.0
62.0
61.7

Source: Yahoo Finance, August 29, 2008.

In addition to the Fed releasing its beige book on September 3 and interest rate announcements by the Bank of England and the European Central Bank on September 4, next week’s US economic highlights, courtesy of Northern Trust, include the following:

  1. ISM Manufacturing Survey (September 1): The consensus for the manufacturing ISM composite index is 49.5 vs. 50.0 in July. If the consensus forecast is accurate, it would be consistent with weakness in other parts of the economy. Consensus: 49.5 versus 50.0 in July.
  2. Employment Situation (September 5): Payroll employment in August is expected to have dropped by 85,000, taking the tally of consecutive monthly declines to eight. The jobless rate is predicted to have held steady at 5.7%. Consensus: Payrolls: -75,000 versus -51,000 in July, unemployment rate: 5.8% vs. 5.7% in July.
  3. Other reports: Construction spending, auto sales (September 2), factory orders (September 3), ISM non-manufacturing (September 4).

Click here for a summary of Wachovia’s weekly economic and financial commentary.

A summary of the release dates of economic reports in the U.K., Eurozone, Japan and China is provided here. It is important to keep an eye on growth trends in these economies for clues about, among other things, U.S. dollar trends.

Markets
The performance chart obtained from the Wall Street Journal Online shows how different global markets performed during the past week.

31-aug-v5.jpg

Source: Wall Street Journal Online, August 31, 2008.

Equities
Global stock markets, in general, were mixed during the past week. The MSCI World Index rose by 0.6%, with the MSCI Emerging Markets Index closing unchanged.

Among mature markets, the U.S. stock indices were mostly lower, but European stocks turned in good performances, for example Italian Comit 30 Index (+2.6%), French CAC 40 Index (+1.9%) and German XETRA Dax Index (+1.3%). Australia (+4.1%), Japan (+3.2%) and Canada (+2.4%), also shrugged off the gloomy economic outlook and moved higher.

The emerging markets category saw solid gains in Hong Kong (+4.3%) and Taiwan (+2.0%), whereas large declines were registered by Pakistan (-7.9%), Russia (-3.3%) and Turkey (-2.6%). The Russian Trading System Index (16.3%) and the Chinese Shanghai Composite Index (-13.6%) were the worst performers for the month of August.

With the exception of the Russell 2000 Index (+0.3%; YTD -3.5%), the US stock markets closed lower as shown by the major index movements: Dow Jones -0.7% (YTD -13.0%), S&P 500 Index +0.7% (YTD -12.6%) and Nasdaq Composite Index -2.0% (YTD 10.7%).

Particularly noteworthy, the MSCI World Index has outperformed the MSCI Emerging Markets Index over the past month (-1.6% vs -8.2%), past three months (-11.9% vs -21.0%), YTD (-15.4% vs -23.2%), and also since the stock market peaks of October 2007 (-20.7% versus -28.6%).

31-aug-v6.jpg

The Russell 2000 Index is trading above both its 50- and 200-day moving averages, whereas the Dow Jones Industrial Index, S&P 500 Index and Nasdaq Composite Index are above their 50-day averages but still below the important 200-day line – often used as an indicator of the primary trend.

Click here or on the thumbnail below for a market map, courtesy of Finviz.com, providing a quick overview of the performance of the various segments of the S&P 500 Index over the week.

click to enlarge

The thrifts and mortgage finance group (+16%) was the best-performing group for the week, led by Freddie Mac (FRE) and Fannie Mae (FNM), up 61% and 37% respectively. This is a strong reversal from being the worst performing group during the previous week with a decline of 23%. The stocks were driven down recently by speculation on whether a government bailout was imminent, a prospect that would probably wipe out the equity holders. Those concerns seemed to diminish last week after some analysts estimated that the firms had enough capital to last at least until next year.

31-aug-v8.jpg

The homebuilding group was the second-best performing group, gaining 9% on housing reports being interpreted as showing signs of a stabilizing market.

The trucking group (-7%) was the worst performer, led by its single member, Ryder System (R). A brokerage analyst downgraded the trucking sector, predicting that freight volumes in the peak shipping season through November might be weaker than expected because of the soft U.S. economy.

The Internet retail group (-6%) was the second-worst performer, led by its largest member, Amazon (AMZN). A blog posting by a newspaper reporter raised the topic again of how well Amazon’s Kindle electronic book reader was actually selling.

Fixed-interest instruments
Global government bond yields were mostly lower during the past week, as investors dismissed the threat of inflation and priced in concerns about a global recession.

The ten-year U.S. Treasury Note declined by four basis points to 3.83%, the U.K. ten-year Gilt yield by 13 basis points to 4.48%, the German ten-year Bund yield by five basis points to 4.17% and the Japanese ten-year bond yield by five basis points to 1.42%.

 31-aug-v9.jpg

Currencies
The U.S. dollar maintained its recent rally as the currency benefited from the view that foreign central banks will be quicker to cut rates than the Fed will be to tighten rates.

31-aug-v10.jpg

The past week saw the greenback rising against the euro (+0.7% – a six-month high), the British pound (+1.6%), the Swiss franc (+0.2%), the Australian dollar (+1.2%) and the Canadian dollar (+1.6%).

Sterling has come under further selling pressure as pessimism about the U.K. economic outlook intensified, dropping to a 12-year low on a trade-weighted basis ahead of the Bank of England’s interest rate announcement next week.

The Japanese yen was the only currency to gain against the US dollar during the past week, closing 1.1% higher on the back of better-than-expected economic data and the announcement of a $107 billion fiscal stimulus package.

Commodities
The dollar’s strength and growing concerns of slowing demand knocked dollar-denominated commodity prices as seen in the Reuters/Jeffries CRB Index, which declined by 0.8%.

 31-aug-v11.jpg

West Texas Intermediate crude traded between $115.0 and $118.76 a barrel last week before closing 0.8% up at $115.46 on Friday. The gain was relatively small given the impending arrival of Hurricane Gustav and concerns about the geopolitical situation with Russia, but word from the Department of Energy that it would release strategic oil stocks to combat any disruption kept oil prices in check. (The Gulf of Mexico is responsible for 25% of U.S. crude oil production and 15% of US natural gas production.)

The chart below shows the past week’s movements for the various commodities:

 31-aug-v12.jpg

I would like to wish all of you a fabulous Labor Day weekend.

This article has 8 comments:

  •  
    Aug 31 07:57 AM
    The title says it all, "era of caution". Very few are calling for a V shape recovery in stocks or the economy. Momentum traders will not miss much by observing markets carefully except for a well timed trade here and there. UK Chancellor Darling says the UK is facing the worst financial crisis in 60 years and it is getting WORSE. Prieur's call for a true upturn in 2h2010 appears to be on course; Jeremy Grantham says this financial crisis will last 2 years at least which is consistent with Prieur's view of the market.
    Reply
  •  
    LLOk anyone who invests in financials is NOT using caution. Some rouge employee or Mozilo like CEO can cripple even the best institution .Since 1957-2003 18 of the top 20 companies factoring in reinvested dividends were conumer goods or pharma. Altria was BY FAR number 1 and is still "cheap" . Financials have NEVE been certain. Who can understand a CDO? What sane person gives aloan for more than ahouses "inflated value"?
    Reply
  •  
    Aug 31 11:00 AM
    Thanks for a very helpful and comprehensive summary.
    Reply
  •  
    Aug 31 11:00 AM
    Thanks for a very helpful and comprehensive summary.
    Reply
  •  
    Aug 31 02:05 PM
    Lacked focus not to mention wordy. The problem with the exhaustive posts of facts ad nausean is one has no idea of all matter, few, or none. In the end the credit squeeze is going to hurt employment and output and no one has a clue how long the sequence will take to work through, or what the outcome will be. We are in a credit warp, which as you will recall from star wars, was one of the worse things that can happen on a star voyage, as I recall.
    Reply
  •  
    Aug 31 04:01 PM
    I like your perspective, Prieur. Thanks for the article.
    Reply
  •  
    Sep 01 02:07 AM
    "The rally’s lack of breadth, however, is worrying, causing Richard Russell (Dow Theory Letters) to warn:

    If July 15 was a true bottom, the market should be roaring up today, and that’s not what’s been happening. Caution is warranted!"

    It's statements like these that show how many boobs there are in the financial misinformation business. Did this 'author' really think that a market bottom in July would result in a 'roaring' upmarket in August. That's why I use the term 'boob' (what other term is there for these people - financial misinformation 'boobs'). All this gloom and doom and then in the same breath (hold your breath now) you get a statement like this: "The thrifts and mortgage finance group (+16%) was the best-performing group for the week, led by Freddie Mac (FRE) and Fannie Mae (FNM), up 61% and 37% respectively. This is a strong reversal from being the worst performing group during the previous week with a decline of 23%. The stocks were driven down recently by speculation on whether a government bailout was imminent, a prospect that would probably wipe out the equity holders. Those concerns seemed to diminish last week after some analysts estimated that the firms had enough capital to last at least until next year." Oh Boy! I sure see a lot of concern about markets in that statement - enough capital to last until at least next year!

    No, the financial markets are not going to collapse. They can't. There are too many Mozillo (sp?) types out there that would (should) have to go to jail for the fraud they perpetrated, and that ain't going to happen. Massive price corrections - you bet - and there should be. The days of hyper-inflated home prices are over - and should of never happened (except for those Mozillo types that made it happen and will never be prosecuted) Operating on equity - not anymore - there is none in this market. All you have to work with now is your dollar per hour wage - no stated income.

    Remember Silverado? Boy did we make it through all that or what! And all those millionaires 10 - 15 years later. They laughed all the way to the bank - with financials stocks. You know what they say, 'Buy low, sell high'. So, be a true investor and quit worrying about what the various markets are doing and simply follow your gut which says 'WaMu is really low right now, so is Feddie Mac (I have positions in both), maybe I should buy now". Don't be scared! After you buy them put them away for say, ten years. Don't get rattled by the short and pump guys - they're day traders. After ten years take a look at the stocks you bought. I bet you'll be laughing all the way to the bank.



    Reply
  •  
    yo! tmdag. 10 years a long time man!

    whidbey dude, like the star war thing. gotta thing goin on my blog all about the 'flation nebula "dorktreck : lost in space."

    thanks Prie
    Reply
Articles on related themes